If a bank refuses to pay under a letter of credit, the buyer may still be liable for the price. In Moeve Trading S.A.U. v Mael Trading FZ LLC[1], the English Commercial Court (Court) confirmed that, unless clearly agreed otherwise, a letter of credit operates as a conditional rather than absolute payment and does not extinguish the buyer’s underlying obligation to pay if the credit is not honoured.
It is standard market practice for parties engaged in the international sale of commodities to rely on irrevocable documentary letters of credit as the primary mechanism for securing cross-border payments. Letters of credit provide sellers the assurance of payment through a bank undertaking, while allowing buyers to defer payment until shipment has occurred.
The relationship between payment by letters of credit and allocation of risk and title under Incoterms (including FOB, CFR and CIF) can be critical if payment under a letter of credit fails. The decision clarifies the parties’ obligations in this context, and a similar position is likely under New Zealand law.
Background
On 4 April 2024, Moeve Trading (Seller) and Mael Trading (Buyer) concluded a contract for the sale of gasoline and gasoil (Cargo), FOB Algeciras.
The Cepsa Trading 2021 General Terms and Conditions (GTCs) were incorporated into the sale contract (Sale Contract), providing that title passed on shipment.
Clause 3.2 of the Sale Contract required the Buyer to pay the price within 60 days of the bill of lading date, and clause 3.3 required the Buyer to open irrevocable documentary letters of credit (LCs) acceptable to the Seller.
Two LCs, issued by Bank of Africa United Kingdom plc and confirmed by J.P. Morgan Chase Bank NA, were in place by 21 June 2024 and required presentation of specified documents, including original bills of lading. The Cargo was shipped on 12 July 2024.
Payment under the LCs was subsequently refused by the issuing bank in September-October 2024 for reasons not material to the Court’s decision.
The Seller sued the Buyer for the price pursuant to section 49(1) Sale of Goods Act 1979[2] (Sale of Goods Act), asserting title had passed and the Buyer had an obligation to pay under the Sale Contract.
Was the buyer’s obligation to pay discharged by its procurement of the LCs?
The first issue was whether the Buyer’s procurement of the confirmed LCs discharged its payment obligation absolutely, or operated only as conditional payment, leaving the Buyer liable if the issuing bank refused to pay.
The Buyer argued that arranging the LCs in accordance with the Sale Contract satisfied its payment obligation, and the Seller was not entitled to seek payment directly.
The Seller argued that, unless clearly agreed otherwise, LCs are only conditional payment, so the Buyer remains liable if the letter of credit fails.
The Court reviewed the authorities, including WJ Alan & Company Ltd v El Nasr Export & Import Co[3] and Newman Industries v Indo-British Industries[4] and confirmed that letters of credit normally operate as conditional, not absolute, payment unless the contract clearly provides otherwise.
Where a letter of credit operates as conditional payment and title to the buyer has not passed, the seller has recourse to the buyer only where the seller is not responsible for the bank’s refusal to pay (for example, it has complied with its obligations by presenting the documents).
In this case, the Court found that the parties intended the Buyer to remain primarily responsible for paying the price upon the Seller’s presentation of the required documents. The Buyer was obliged to arrange the LCs to cover that payment, but clause 33.1 of the GTCs (which provided that unless otherwise agreed in the Sale Contract, payment was to be made by irrevocable documentary letter of credit) did not displace the Buyer’s underlying obligation in clause 3.2. If there was any inconsistency, clause 3.2, requiring payment within 60 days of the bill of lading date, constituted the necessary “agreement otherwise” for the purposes of clause 33.1. Issuing the LCs did not discharge the Buyer’s obligation to pay the price to the Seller in accordance with section 49(1) Sale of Goods Act, because title had already passed to the Buyer on shipment.
Had there been a proper tender of documents to trigger the Buyer’s liability to pay?
The second issue was whether the Buyer was entitled to refuse payment on the basis that the Seller had not physically handed over the original bills of lading and other contractual documents, or whether it was sufficient for the Seller to offer to provide them concurrently in exchange for payment.
The Buyer argued that no liability to pay arose until the Seller physically delivered the bills of lading and other required documents.
The Seller argued that the Sale Contract entitled it to retain documents pending payment. The GTCs also established that the obligation to present documents and the duty to pay were concurrent obligations, meaning the Seller only needed to be ready, willing, and able to hand over documents at the same time as payment.
The Court agreed with the Seller. It held that “presentation” and “tender” in this context mean offering documents for acceptance, not handing them over in advance of payment. An offer to exchange the documents for payment was sufficient and consistent with section 28 of the Sale of Goods Act[5], which treats payment and delivery as concurrent conditions unless otherwise agreed. The Seller had in fact tendered the documents and therefore the Buyer’s refusal to pay was wrongful within the meaning of the Sale of Goods Act[6]. The Court granted summary judgment for the full price.
Key Takeaways
Although an English Commercial Court decision, the principles applied are relevant to international commodity sale contracts generally, particularly for traders operating under FOB, CFR or CIF[7] terms and relying on payment by letters of credit.
- Letters of credit are ordinarily conditional payment: Unless the contract clearly states that a letter of credit is to serve as absolute payment, letters of credit function only as conditional payment. If the letter of credit fails, the seller may still pursue the buyer directly for the price, in particular where title has passed (subject to the terms of the contract and the circumstances of non-payment).
- Passing of title remains central to a seller’s right to claim the price: Where property in the goods has passed (as it did in this case on FOB shipment under the GTCs), section 49(1) Sale of Goods Act allows a direct claim for the price, notwithstanding difficulties under the letter of credit, or third‑party events affecting payment, provided the seller is ready to satisfy its concurrent obligation to present documents. An analogous position is likely under New Zealand law pursuant to the equivalent section 191 of the Contract and Commercial Law Act 2017.
- Tender of documents does not require prior physical handover: Where payment is required “against presentation”, a seller does not need to deliver original documents in advance. An offer to provide the documents in exchange for payment is sufficient. Buyers cannot insist on prior physical delivery as a means to delay or avoid liability for payment.
This information was current at the time of publication. Our Transport and Logistics team has extensive experience in dealing with international commodities contracts, including disputes that arise. If you have any questions regarding this case or your commodities contracts, contact the Transport and Logistics team or your usual contact at Hesketh Henry.
Disclaimer: The information contained in this article is current at the date of publishing and is of a general nature. It should be used as a guide only and not as a substitute for obtaining legal advice. Specific legal advice should be sought where required.
[1] [2026] EWHC 17 (Comm)
[2] Sale of Goods Act 1979 (UK)
[3] [1972] 2 QB 189 (CA)
[4] [1956] 2 Lloyd’s Rep 219
[5] Equivalent to s157 Contract and Commercial Law Act 2017 (Payment and delivery are concurrent conditions)
[6] s49(1) Sale of Goods Act
[7] Incoterms 2020