Partner

Helen Macfarlane

LLB
Profile
Helen is a partner in our Disputes Group and a member of our Construction and Insurance teams.

Helen studied English and Politics for her BA and completed an MA in Philosophy at Auckland University before studying law at Oxford.  She was admitted as a barrister in London before moving to New York where she worked as a litigation attorney for 15 years with a leading US and international law firm Shearman and Sterling, specialising in commercial litigation and international arbitration.

Since joining Hesketh Henry in 2007, Helen has developed a strong practice focussing on the cross-over areas of construction and insurance law.  She has acted in leaky building cases (including the seminal High Court Byron Avenue trial) and Construction Contracts Act adjudications and has provided advice relating to projects in the residential, commercial, energy and horizontal infrastructure sectors.  Leveraging her international experience, Helen has conducted and advised on investigations and negotiations in relation to projects funded by international funding institutions (such as the World Bank and JICA) in the Asia / Pacific region.  Helen provides up-front drafting advice in relation to residential and commercial construction projects for both contractors and subcontractors.  Complementing her construction expertise, Helen’s insurance practice focuses on professional indemnity insurance, particularly in the construction consultant / construction defects space, and more generally in advising on general liability, material damage and contract works policies.  She has added New Zealand domestic arbitration in the valuation and commercial rent review areas to her previous international arbitration experience.

Helen is President of the Society of Construction Law New Zealand, having been an elected Council member since 2018 and Vice-President from 2022 to July 2024.  She regularly presents at SCL events as well as presenting and / or chairing seminars for Thompson Reuters and Legalwise in the construction and insurance areas.

Need to get in touch with Helen?
Send a message to Helen
Experience

Examples of work completed by Helen include:

  • Acting for one of New Zealand’s largest multi-disciplinary construction consulting companies in high value claims involving multiple parties and complex design, engineering and construction issues.  Helen also advises this client on an ongoing, as-needed basis on contractual clauses and on issues arising from consortium projects in New Zealand and Asia, as well as on contractual/payment claim disputes with clients and/or sub-consultants.
  • Acting as defence counsel in High Court proceedings arising out of the Transmission Gully roading project.
  • Acting as defence counsel in High Court proceedings arising out of the October 2019 fire at the New Zealand International Convention Centre.
  • Acting for major insurer in successfully defending High Court proceedings relating to Christchurch rebuild (Body Corporate 335089 v Vero Insurance New Zealand Ltd [2020] NZHC 2353)
  • Representing a major insurer providing drafting advice on a suite of construction contracts for use in the Christchurch rebuild.  Covered all aspects of drafting and risk analysis, including insurances required for construction projects.
  • Providing advice to a consultant regarding contractual terms of retention by a consortium in connection with a tender for a major PPP infrastructure project.
  • Providing advice to insurer on cover and potential claims in relation to Royal Commission of Inquiry into building failures caused by the Canterbury earthquakes; extensive work with engineers in connection with the same.
  • Successfully defending a project manager in seminal High Court trial relating to leaky building claims in a multi-unit residential development. The claim against our client was dismissed, with costs awarded against the plaintiffs. (Body Corporate No 189855 v North Shore City Council (Byron Avenue) HC Auckland CIV-2005-404-5561, 25 July 2008 – 2008 WL 2930653)
  • Representing project managers in a High Court leaky building case.  Negotiated a settlement where our client paid nothing except its own costs.
  • Representing major architectural/engineering firm in multi-party residential leaky building case.  Negotiated early dismissal from the case for a nominal payment.
  • Representing project manager in leaky building case before WHRS.  Spear-headed negotiations on part of defendant group to achieve settlement where plaintiffs recovered less than half the amount originally claimed.
  • Representing clients in a number of Construction Contracts Act cases.  Helen has experience representing both claimants and respondents.
  • Advising insurers concerning claims of professional negligence/misconduct of Engineer to contract arising out of Construction Contracts Act claims relating to a roading project.
  • Advising insurers and defending a firm of solicitors against allegations of equitable fraud and breaches of fiduciary duty resulting from representations dating back to 1989.
  • Advising insurers and defending a firm of solicitors against allegations of breach of contract and negligence in relation to the transfer and development of a luxury property in Queenstown.
  • Representing a major property investor/management company in a commercial rent review arbitration involving complex valuation and geotechnical evidence.
  • Representing property management company in proceedings under the Declaratory Judgment Act arising out of an encumbrance dispute.
  • Advising a major national retailer in connection with resolving a long-standing lease dispute following the Christchurch earthquakes.  Helen achieved a negotiated settlement several months after becoming involved.
  • Representing a major consulting company in connection with a dispute with its landlord over termination of its lease.  Helen arranged for a fast-track mediation resulting in a commercial settlement approximately one month after she became involved.
  • Advice to group of companies with New Zealand parent on New Zealand’s sanctions regime in connection with doing business in Iran.
  • Overseeing and conducting internal investigations in relation to the conduct of IFI funded infrastructure projects in the Asia / Pacific region and reporting to funders including the World Bank and JICA.
  • Representing insurers in complex multi-unit claims arising out of the Canterbury earthquakes.
  • Advising insurers in relation to policy response under professional indemnity, general liability, material damage and contract works polices.
Media
Publications
  • Getting the Deal Through – Construction 2019 (Accreditation: Reproduced with permission from Law Business Research Ltd. This article was first published in Lexology Getting the Deal Through – Construction 2019 (Published: July 2019). For further information please visit www.gettingthedealthrough.com

Insights & Opinion / Helen Macfarlane

iStock  Construction dpi
“More than an opinion”: criminal liability arising from PS4 producer statements under the Building Act 2004
In Solicitor-General’s Reference (No 1 of 2022) from CRI-2021-463-55 ([2022] NZHC 556) [2024] NZCA 514 the Court of Appeal was asked to consider the following question: Was the Court correct to find...
15.10.2024 Posted in Construction & Disputes
Wielding the Secateurs: The High Court’s Pruning of Potentially Disruptive Decisions
Every now and then courts have to self-correct to prevent errant off-shoots of legal reasoning advancing into the law.  In the decision, IAG New Zealand Ltd v Degen [2024] NZHC 397, the High Court t...
19.09.2024 Posted in Insurance
Construction Framework Wide BW
Major milestone passed – NZS3910:2023 expected in time to fill Christmas stockings
As the most widely adopted standard form construction contract in NZ, NZS 3910 was more than ready for updated conditions given the changes in the industry since its last review in 2013.  After almos...
09.10.2023 Posted in Construction
Construction
A Landmark Change? – Proposed reform of the occupational regulation of engineers
Engineers engage in building work that is critical to public safety. Despite this, few restrictions are placed on who can carry out and supervise complex and specialised projects that require high levels of professional judgement, skill and technical competence.
07.04.2022 Posted in Construction
Proposed Reforms to Building Act and Regulations
There are major changes to the Building Act on the horizon that will impact the entire construction sector including manufacturers, builders, building consent authorities, consultants and many others ...
06.11.2020 Posted in Construction & Disputes
COVID-19: Industries interrupted: A call for clarity in respect of Business Interruption Cover
Understandably, businesses worldwide are looking for financial support to offset losses flowing from the restrictions governments have placed on how we can conduct business as part of global and local responses to control the spread of COVID-19.
13.05.2020 Posted in Corporate & Commercial & Insurance
Construction contract
COVID-19: Impacts on Construction Contracts
New Zealand entered Covid-19 Alert Level 4 at 11.59pm on Wednesday 25 March.  Anyone not working in essential services is required to stay at home.  This restriction does not apply to building or co...
08.04.2020 Posted in Construction
SEND AN ENQUIRY