17.02.2021

Construction Contracts Act Enforcement Costs

Cubo Projects Ltd v S&S Import Solutions Ltd

The High Court in Cubo Projects Ltd v S&S Import Solutions Ltd [2020] NZHC 3234 stopped short of awarding indemnity or increased costs to a payee for an action taken to enforce a “debt due” under the Construction Contracts Act 2002 (CCA). 

In 2018, Cubo Projects Ltd (Cubo), as contractor, served payment claims on S&S Import Solutions Ltd (S&S), as principal.  S&S did not issue payment schedules in response as required by the CCA and only paid a portion of what was claimed.  Cubo issued a statutory demand for the unpaid balance on the basis this was a debt due under the CCA.  S&S also ignored this.  Cubo therefore applied to put S&S into liquidation.  Only then did S&S take action – attempting to challenge the legitimacy of Cubo’s payment claims, before the parties settled on terms set out in a consent judgment.  The outcome of the settlement (excluding costs) was that S&S would pay the outstanding balance on the payment claims of $9,412.71.

The only remaining matter to be resolved was costs. A plainly exasperated Associate Judge Johnson noted that the costs question was referred back to the Court after the parties could not reach agreement.

Cubo sought its actual costs of $19,927 on an indemnity basis – arguing that it had an unimpeachable right to payment under the CCA with its “pay now, argue later” principle, which S&S only accepted at the eleventh hour and after Cubo had said it would seek indemnity costs.  S&S resisted this and argued that scale costs should apply and these should be downgraded from the usual 2B basis to 1A on the grounds it was a simple matter and only a small (c$9,000) sum was at stake.

While the Court said that Cubo was justified in criticising the defendant for its “somewhat cavalier approach” to both the payment claims and the statutory demand, it declined to award indemnity costs.  The Court agreed with S&S that the proceeding had been straightforward and noted that while s 23(2)(a)(ii) of the CCA allows for recovery of actual enforcement costs this is limited to “actual and reasonable costs” (emphasis added).  In this case, consideration of whether the costs incurred were reasonable pointed away from an award of indemnity costs.  Costs were awarded on a 2B basis ($11,830.50), which was still higher than the 1A basis sought by S&S.

While some in the construction sector may be disappointed to see this outcome, the decision is consistent with previous authorities where the Courts have confirmed that the intention behind s 23 is for payees to be able to recover enforcement costs, provided the quantum was reasonable and not “excessively high”, and that some proportionality is required when determining a party’s costs entitlement.

Cubo confirms that parties can recover enforcement costs in relation debts due under the CCA, but there is no automatic right to indemnity costs.  A more holistic assessment is required based on what is “reasonable” in the circumstances.

If you have any questions about the article, please get in touch with our Construction Team or your usual contact at Hesketh Henry.

 

Disclaimer:  The information contained in this article is current at the date of publishing and is of a general nature.  It should be used as a guide only and not as a substitute for obtaining legal advice.  Specific legal advice should be sought where required.

 

Do you need expert legal advice?
Contact the expert team at Hesketh Henry.
Kerry
Media contact - Kerry Browne
Please contact Kerry with any media enquiries and with any questions related to marketing or sponsorships on +64 9 375 8747 or via email.

Related Articles / Insights & Opinion

Fern forest NZ
Bioenergy in New Zealand: Fuels for the Future?
The energy transition from combustion fuels to low carbon alternatives is viewed as critical in the race to cut global CO2 emissions and reach climate targets.  We look at some of the opportunities p...
14.11.2023 Posted in Business Advice & Climate Change & Forestry
Will Wide BW
A well drafted will is a craft
The New Zealand do-it-yourself “DIY” attitude and way of life is not limited to home improvements, but sometimes also extends to wills.  Recently we had a DIY $5.99 fill in the blanks will acros...
07.11.2023 Posted in Private Wealth
rsz large pillars
Health and Safety: The Consequences of Dishonesty
Siddhartha Gautama said that lies are like huge, gaudy vessels, the rafters of which are rotten and worm-eaten, and that those who embark in them are fated to be shipwrecked.  Two remarkable health a...
03.11.2023 Posted in Employment & Health & Safety
Properly sequencing your Construction Adjudications: Henry Construction Projects Ltd v Alu-Fix (UK) Ltd
According to the UK’s Technology and Construction Court (TCC) (in Henry Construction Projects Ltd v Alu-Fix (UK) Ltd [2023] EWHC 2010) valid payment claims must be paid before the underlying merits ...
30.10.2023 Posted in Construction & Disputes
Key change to rules on distribution of surplus assets under the new Incorporated Societies Act 2022
On 5 October 2023, the new Incorporated Societies Act 2022 (2022 Act) came fully into force, replacing the Incorporated Societies Act 1908 (1908 Act). One of the key requirements under the 2022 Act is...
18.10.2023 Posted in Business Advice
Construction Framework Wide BW
Major milestone passed – NZS3910:2023 expected in time to fill Christmas stockings
As the most widely adopted standard form construction contract in NZ, NZS 3910 was more than ready for updated conditions given the changes in the industry since its last review in 2013.  After almos...
09.10.2023 Posted in Construction
Time is money – availability provisions in employment agreements and the requirement to compensate
What happens when an availability provision is non-compliant because it does not allow for compensation, but the employee is not “required” to work additional hours?  Can the employee still be sa...
21.09.2023 Posted in Business Advice & Employment
SEND AN ENQUIRY
Send us an enquiry

For expert legal advice, please complete the form below or call us on (09) 375 8700.