9.05.2018

Job Application Forms and Questions – Have you been sterilised?

A job application form seems so simple, however they can be harder to make legally compliant than you might think.

In the Media

An extreme example recently reported by Fairfax Media was a series of ‘traumatic’ questions Chevron Australia was asking job applicants.  The questions included:

  • Details of sexually transmitted diseases;
  • What the date of the applicant’s last period was;
  • Whether the applicant had ever been pregnant and, if so, how many times;
  • How many abortions and stillborn children the applicant had had;
  • How many “normal” children had been born;
  • Whether the applicant or the applicant’s partner had been sterilised;
  • Whether the applicant and partner have tried for at least 12 months to conceive a child; and
  • Whether a physician has ever told the applicant or the applicant’s partner that either one of them has a medical condition that prevents having a child.

When challenged, the company’s initial response was that the medical documents were guided by industry standards to ensure that staff were safe and fit to work, and that they were lawful.  It denied that candidates who met the requirements of a position were discriminated against based on medical history.

The article reported an Australian employment lawyer stating that the Chevron form “would breach several discrimination and privacy laws”. The lawyer asked if “the information that is being asked reasonable to the employee carrying out their job?”.

Legal Requirements

New Zealand law is very similar.  Prospective employers should only ask applicants lawful questions that are relevant to the job.

The three key pieces of legislation to consider are:

  • Employment Relations Act 2000;
  • Human Rights Act 1993; and
  • Privacy Act 1993.

The Human Rights Act 1993 applies to job applicants.  Both the Employment Relations Act and the Human Rights Act set out a long list of 11 prohibited grounds of discrimination.  This list includes:

  • Sex (which itself includes pregnancy and childbirth);
  • Disability (which includes the presence in the body of organisms capable of causing illness);
  • Age; and
  • Family status (which includes having the responsibility for the care of children).

It is not only unlawful to discriminate on the basis of one of the 11 grounds, but it is also unlawful to ask questions that would indicate an intention to discriminate.  By asking a question an employer is indicating that it is going do something with the information.  It might appear to an applicant that the employer is asking the question with the intention of not employing him or her depending on what his or her answer is.

The Privacy Act prohibits personal information from being collected by an employer unless the information is collected for a lawful purpose connected with a function or activity of the employer and the collection of the information is necessary for that purpose.  In other words, an employer is not allowed to collect personal information unless it actually needs it to make a recruitment decision.

Top Tip for Employers

When drafting an application form it is useful to keep in mind the following questions:

  • Is this question relevant to the role or job?
  • Do I need to know the answer to this question?
  • Is this question lawful?

These questions all need to be considered in relation to the actual job functions of the particular job.  As an example, lifting may be critical for a packing role but not for an administration role.  As a consequence, an application form that asked a lifting question may be satisfactory for one role but considered discriminatory for the other.  Where an employer has a range of functions across different roles, a general application form will be of limited value, and role specific application questions may be required.

As an end note, it seems that Chevron Australia took advice following the outcry in the media.  Fairfax Media subsequently reported that Chevron Australia had withdrawn its application form to amend it to ask only medical information relevant to the position.

Do you need expert legal advice?
Contact the expert team at Hesketh Henry.
Kerry_100x100 1
Media contact - Kerry Browne
Please contact Kerry with any media enquiries and with any questions related to marketing or sponsorships on +64 9 375 8747 or via email.

Related Articles / Insights & Opinion

COVID-19 Redundancies: Cutting Corners Courts Censure
The Employment Relations Authority (Authority) has recently issued a determination that considers redundancies implemented due to the Government’s COVID-19 restrictions:  De Wys and Jenney v Solly...
13.08.2020 Posted in COVID-19 & Employment Law
Losses caused by 2011 earthquakes not a “series of losses”
Moore v IAG New Zealand Limited [2020] NZCA 319
12.08.2020 Posted in Insurance Law
Cancelled Plans and Future Liabilities: A post lockdown annual holidays FAQ
COVID-19 has not only hit many employers hard in terms of economic impact, it has also confronted employers with many employment challenges that require urgent attention.
04.08.2020 Posted in Business Advice & Employment Law
A high bar to set aside statutory demands to enforce adjudication determinations under the Construction Contracts Act 2002
The “pay now argue later” principle underpins the Construction Contracts Act 2002 (CCA).  The recent decision of C&R Property Development Ltd v MR Civil Ltd confirms the importance of this pr...
31.07.2020 Posted in Construction Law
Design life in the spotlight
Blackpool Borough Council v Volkerfitzpatrick [2020] EWHC 1523 (TCC) In 2009, Blackpool Borough Council (Principal), as principal, contracted with Volkerfitzpatrick Ltd (Contractor), as head contracto...
COVID-19 and the Future of Force Majeure
Not since Y2K have force majeure clauses been of so much focus.
Shareholder Agreements:  The Corporate “Pre-nup”
You’ve got a great idea for a business and you’re pumped to get to work. 
23.06.2020 Posted in Business Advice & Company Law
Send us an enquiry
For expert legal advice, please complete the form below or call us on (09) 375 8700.
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.