29.05.2023

Companies (Directors Duties) Amendment Bill – Recap and Update

A bill proposing to expressly include ESG factors in the context of a director’s exercise of corporate power has recently failed to obtain Select Committee support.  Hesketh Henry’s Business Advice team takes a look at the controversial bill and its recent legislative history.

As environmental, social and governance (ESG) considerations continue to receive increased attention from organisations around the world, these considerations came into sharper focus from a NZ legislative perspective in 2021 when MP Duncan Webb introduced a bill which proposed to amend well established legislation regarding directors duties in New Zealand.

The bill focussed on section 131 of the Companies Act 1993.  Section 131 provides that when exercising powers or performing their duties, the director of a company must act in good faith and in what they believe are the best interests of the company.  The bill proposed to add the following subsection 5: 

(5) To avoid doubt, a director of a company may, when determining the best interests of the company, take into account recognised environmental, social and governance factors, such as: 

(a) recognising the principles of the Treaty of Waitangi (Te Tiriti o Waitangi):

(b) reducing adverse environmental impacts:

(c) upholding high standards of ethical behaviour:

(d) following fair and equitable employment practices:

(e) recognising the interests of the wider community. 

The policy statement to the bill outlined that its aim was to make clear that a director, in acting as the mind and will of the company, can take actions which take into account wider matters than the financial bottom-line. 

In early May 2023, the Economic Development, Science and Innovation Committee released its report on the bill.  The report noted that the Committee was unable to agree that the bill should pass, but recommended amendments to the bill, if it were to proceed any further.  The Committee also noted that the new subsection 5 could be shortened and still achieve its intended effect, per the following wording:

(5) To avoid doubt, in considering the best interests of a company or holding company for the purposes of this section, a director may consider matters other than the maximisation of profit.

Key concerns raised by the Committee about the bill were:

  • The bill as introduced could have unintended consequences insofar that it may confuse directors and give the impression that these ESG factors should be given more weight than others.
  • Reference to Te Tiriti o Waitangi could be an additional source of confusion because the relationship between the Crown and Māori is governed by Te Tiriti and this relationship does not typically include other individuals or private entities.
  • Its introduction could create inconsistencies within the Companies Act and with other legislation insofar that if this subsection was included in section 131 and not in other areas of the Companies Act, or in other laws (such as the Incorporated Societies Act 2022), there could be confusion as to how they are to be interpreted or why they are not framed in a similar way.

The bill has also been criticised by other commentators for its reference to ‘recognised’ in the phrase ‘recognised environmental, social and governance factors’ – without giving any clarification on what those recognised factors are.  Other commentators have also pointed out that a prudent director would already be considering ESG related matters (for example, the extent to which adverse environmental impacts may result from a corporate decision) and therefore the bill does not add meaningfully to the legislation.

Our team will be following further developments in this area. 

If you would like further information about any of the matters discussed in this article, or how it may affect your business, please get in touch with our Business Advice team or your usual contact at Hesketh Henry.

Disclaimer:  The information contained in this article is current at the date of publishing and is of a general nature.  It should be used as a guide only and not as a substitute for obtaining legal advice.  Specific legal advice should be sought where required.

Do you need expert legal advice?
Contact the expert team at Hesketh Henry.
Kerry
Media contact - Kerry Browne
Please contact Kerry with any media enquiries and with any questions related to marketing or sponsorships on +64 9 375 8747 or via email.

Related Articles / Insights & Opinion

Mind your business: What happens when an employer uses an employee’s personal information?
A recent decision by the Human Rights Review Tribunal (the Tribunal) provides a noteworthy reminder of the importance of privacy rights and obligations in the workplace.  In BMN v Stonewood Group Lim...
14.02.2025 Posted in Employment
Construction Framework Wide BW
Public consultation on NZS 3916:2025 and NZS 3917:2025
Public consultation on the draft DZ 3916 Conditions of contract for building and civil engineering – Design and construct and DZ 3917 Conditions of contract for building and civil engineering – F...
13.02.2025 Posted in Construction
Court of Appeal rules Gloriavale’s challenges to BNZ decision to close its account are not seriously arguable
Background BNZ made the decision to close the accounts of 16 entities associated with the Gloriavale Christian Community following a decision by senior management that this action was appropriate give...
07.02.2025 Posted in Disputes & Insurance
Milford sound
Government unveils ‘Invest New Zealand’ agency to position NZ as premier FDI destination
Yesterday, the Prime Minister Rt Hon Christopher Luxon announced the Government’s plan to establish a new foreign investment agency, as part of his ‘State of the Nation’ speech in Auckland.  We...
Construction Framework Wide BW
Construction insurance cover: Sky UK Ltd v Riverstone Managing Agency Ltd
Parties to a building contract usually take out insurance to protect the contract works from damage from unintended events such as vandalism or a flood.  The policy is intended to cover the cost of r...
23.01.2025 Posted in Construction & Insurance
Family sunset BW
Have you updated your Will since becoming a parent? The importance of nominating a Testamentary Guardian
For parents, preparing a Will or Deed that appoints a testamentary guardian is an important step to ensure the well-being of your children if you die. A testamentary guardian is a person who after a p...
22.01.2025 Posted in Private Wealth
vecteezy calendar and santa on table happy new year and xmas concept  ext e
Let me check my calen-deer – Leave entitlements over the festive period
What you need to know about holiday and leave entitlements over the festive season
18.12.2024 Posted in Employment
SEND AN ENQUIRY
Send us an enquiry

For expert legal advice, please complete the form below or call us on (09) 375 8700.