Marlborough District Council v Altimarloch Joint Venture Ltd [2012] NZSC11

Elias CJBlanchard JTipping JMcGrath JAnderson J
Contract Measure of damagesLoss of bargain: difference in the value of land with and without water rights ($400,000).

Loss of bargain is the ‘normal measure of damages in sale transactions.

Cost of cure ($1.055m)Cost of cure ($1.055m).

The ‘normal’ measure of damages is the performance cost of the contract.

Cost of cure ($1.055m).

The ‘normal’ measure of damages in sale contracts is the loss of bargain/difference in value.

The ‘normal’ measure in service contracts is the performance cost.

Loss of bargain ($400,000) (per Elias J)


Council owes duty of careYes (per Tipping J)Yes (per Tipping j)YesYes (per Tipping J)Yes (per Tipping J)
Council caused lossNoYes (until plaintiffs paid by vendors then no)NoYesYes (per McGrath J)
Tort measure of damages (not directly appealed)Difference between the purchase price and the true value ($125,000).Difference between the purchase price and the true value ($125,000).Difference between the purchase price and the true value ($125,000).Difference between the purchase price and the true value ($125,000).Difference between the purchase price and the true value ($125,000) (per McGrath J)
Contribution allowedNoNoNoYes (50%)Yes (per McGrath J)
Do you need expert legal advice?
Contact the expert team at Hesketh Henry.
Kerry_100x100 1
Media contact - Kerry Browne
Please contact Kerry with any media enquiries and with any questions related to marketing or sponsorships on +64 9 375 8747 or via email.

Related Articles / Insights & Opinion

Updated Subcontract Agreement: SA-2017
The SA-2009 form of Subcontract Agreement is commonly used in the construction industry. It has undergone a review and a new SA-2017 form has been produced.
3.07.2018 Posted in Construction Law & Health & Safety Law
Distribution Agreements – 6 Key Considerations
While the exact nature and terms of a distribution agreement will vary between industries and jurisdictions, these 6 issues will always be important.
28.06.2018 Posted in Corporate & Commercial law
Continued Importance of IP Protection for Manufacturers
The Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment (MBIE) has recently released a report which identified key trends and challenges for the manufacturing sector (that report can be accessed here). Th...
28.06.2018 Posted in Corporate & Commercial law
Recent Construction Law Decisions and Developments in New Zealand
18.06.2018 Posted in Construction Law
Updated Standard Consultancy Agreements
Two of the most commonly used standard agreements to engage consultants are the ACENZ / Engineering New Zealand (formerly IPENZ) Short Form Agreement (“SFA”) and the Conditions of Contract for Consultancy Services (“CCCS”).
5.06.2018 Posted in Construction Law
Managing Employees’ Mental Health Issues
Ministry of Health statistics confirm that during 2016, 169,454 people accessed mental health services in New Zealand. The law of averages suggests that most workplaces will – to a lesser or greater degree – be affected at some time by an employee’s mental health issue.
31.05.2018 Posted in Employment Law & Health & Safety Law
Managing Medical Incapacity: Enough To Make You Feel Sick?
Managers and HR practitioners often tell us that dealing with employees who are genuinely too sick or injured to work is one of their least favourite tasks. Frankly, we can see why.
31.05.2018 Posted in Employment Law
Send us an enquiry
For expert legal advice, please complete the form below or call us on (09) 375 8700.
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.